Tegan Maharaj

Christoph Becker

Data curation is a field with origins in librarianship and archives, whose scholarship and thinking on data issues go back centuries, if not… (voir plus) millennia. The field of machine learning is increasingly observing the importance of data curation to the advancement of both applications and fundamental understanding of machine learning models - evidenced not least by the creation of the Datasets and Benchmarks track itself. This work provides an analysis of dataset development practices at NeurIPS through the lens of data curation. We present an evaluation framework for dataset documentation, consisting of a rubric and toolkit developed through a literature review of data curation principles. We use the framework to assess the strengths and weaknesses in current dataset development practices of 60 datasets published in the NeurIPS Datasets and Benchmarks track from 2021-2023. We summarize key findings and trends. Results indicate greater need for documentation about environmental footprint, ethical considerations, and data management. We suggest targeted strategies and resources to improve documentation in these areas and provide recommendations for the NeurIPS peer-review process that prioritize rigorous data curation in ML. Finally, we provide results in the format of a dataset that showcases aspects of recommended data curation practices. Our rubric and results are of interest for improving data curation practices broadly in the field of ML as well as to data curation and science and technology studies scholars studying practices in ML. Our aim is to support continued improvement in interdisciplinary research on dataset practices, ultimately improving the reusability and reproducibility of new datasets and benchmarks, enabling standardized and informed human oversight, and strengthening the foundation of rigorous and responsible ML research.

2024-10-29

ArXiv (prépublication)

Quantifying Likeness: A Simple Machine Learning Approach to Identifying Copyright Infringement in (AI-Generated) Artwork

Michaela Drouillard

Ryan Spencer

Nikée Nantambu-Allen

Through study of legal precedent, we propose a pragmatic way to quantify copyright infringement, via stylistic similarity, in AI-generated a… (voir plus)rtwork. Copyright infringement by AI systems is a topic of rapidly-increasing importance as generative AI becomes more widespread and commercial. In contrast to typical work in this field, more in line with a realistic legal setting, our approach quantifies similarity of a set of potentially-infringing "defendant" artworks to a set of copyrighted "plaintiff" artworks. We develop our approach by making use of one of the most litigated artistic creations of this century -- Mickey Mouse. We curate a dataset using Mickey as the plaintiff, and perform hyperparameter search, scaling, and robustness analyses with various defendent artworks from real legal cases to find settings that generalize well. We operationalize similarity via a simple discrimintative task which can be accomplished in a low-resource setting by non-experts -- our aim is to provide a `plug and play' method that is feasible for artists and/or legal experts to use with their own plaintiff sets of artworks. We further demonstrate the viability of our approach by quantifying similarity in a second curated dataset of Maria Prymachenko's art vs. AI-generated images. We conclude by discussing uses of our work in both legal and other settings, including provision of artist compensation.

2024-10-12

NeurIPS.cc/2024/Workshop/SafeGenAi (poster)

The State of Data Curation at NeurIPS: An Assessment of Dataset Development Practices in the Datasets and Benchmarks Track

Eshta Bhardwaj

Harshit Gujral

Siyi Wu

Ciara Zogheib

Christoph Becker

Data curation is a field with origins in librarianship and archives, whose scholarship and thinking on data issues go back centuries, if not… (voir plus) millennia. The field of machine learning is increasingly observing the importance of data curation to the advancement of both applications and fundamental understanding of machine learning models - evidenced not least by the creation of the Datasets and Benchmarks track itself. This work provides an analysis of dataset development practices at NeurIPS through the lens of data curation. We present an evaluation framework for dataset documentation, consisting of a rubric and toolkit developed through a literature review of data curation principles. We use the framework to assess the strengths and weaknesses in current dataset development practices of 60 datasets published in the NeurIPS Datasets and Benchmarks track from 2021-2023. We summarize key findings and trends. Results indicate greater need for documentation about environmental footprint, ethical considerations, and data management. We suggest targeted strategies and resources to improve documentation in these areas and provide recommendations for the NeurIPS peer-review process that prioritize rigorous data curation in ML. Finally, we provide results in the format of a dataset that showcases aspects of recommended data curation practices. Our rubric and results are of interest for improving data curation practices broadly in the field of ML as well as to data curation and science and technology studies scholars studying practices in ML. Our aim is to support continued improvement in interdisciplinary research on dataset practices, ultimately improving the reusability and reproducibility of new datasets and benchmarks, enabling standardized and informed human oversight, and strengthening the foundation of rigorous and responsible ML research.

2024-09-26

NeurIPS.cc/2024/Datasets_and_Benchmarks_Track (spotlight)

Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models

Usman Anwar

Abulhair Saparov

Javier Rando

Daniel Paleka

Miles Turpin

Peter Hase

Ekdeep Singh Lubana

Erik Jenner

Stephen Casper

Oliver Sourbut

Benjamin L. Edelman

Zhaowei Zhang

Mario Günther

Anton Korinek

Jose Hernandez-Orallo

Lewis Hammond

Eric J Bigelow

Alexander Pan

Lauro Langosco

Tomasz Korbak … (voir 22 de plus)

Heidi Chenyu Zhang

Ruiqi Zhong

Sean O hEigeartaigh

Gabriel Recchia

Giulio Corsi

Alan Chan

Markus Anderljung

Lilian Edwards

Aleksandar Petrov

Christian Schroeder de Witt

Danqi Chen

Samuel Albanie

Sumeet Ramesh Motwani

Jakob Nicolaus Foerster

Philip Torr

Florian Tramèr

He He

Atoosa Kasirzadeh

Yejin Choi

2024-09-02

TMLR (accepté)

Implicit meta-learning may lead language models to trust more reliable sources

Dmitrii Krasheninnikov

Egor Krasheninnikov

Bruno Mlodozeniec

We demonstrate that large language models (LLMs) may learn indicators of document usefulness and modulate their updates accordingly. We intr… (voir plus)oduce random strings ("tags") as indicators of usefulness in a synthetic fine-tuning dataset. Fine-tuning on this dataset leads to **implicit meta-learning (IML)**: in further fine-tuning, the model updates to make more use of text that is tagged as useful. We perform a thorough empirical investigation of this phenomenon, finding (among other things) that (i) it occurs in both pretrained LLMs and those trained from scratch, as well as on a vision task, and (ii) larger models and smaller batch sizes tend to give more IML. We also use probing to examine how IML changes the way models store knowledge in their parameters. Finally, we reflect on what our results might imply about the capabilities, risks, and controllability of future AI systems.

2024-07-08

Proceedings of the 41st International Conference on Machine Learning (publié)

proceedings.mlr.press

Machine Learning Data Practices through a Data Curation Lens: An Evaluation Framework

Eshta Bhardwaj

Harshit Gujral

Siyi Wu

Ciara Zogheib

Christoph Becker

Studies of dataset development in machine learning call for greater attention to the data practices that make model development possible and… (voir plus) shape its outcomes. Many argue that the adoption of theory and practices from archives and data curation fields can support greater fairness, accountability, transparency, and more ethical machine learning. In response, this paper examines data practices in machine learning dataset development through the lens of data curation. We evaluate data practices in machine learning as data curation practices. To do so, we develop a framework for evaluating machine learning datasets using data curation concepts and principles through a rubric. Through a mixed-methods analysis of evaluation results for 25 ML datasets, we study the feasibility of data curation principles to be adopted for machine learning data work in practice and explore how data curation is currently performed. We find that researchers in machine learning, which often emphasizes model development, struggle to apply standard data curation principles. Our findings illustrate difficulties at the intersection of these fields, such as evaluating dimensions that have shared terms in both fields but non-shared meanings, a high degree of interpretative flexibility in adapting concepts without prescriptive restrictions, obstacles in limiting the depth of data curation expertise needed to apply the rubric, and challenges in scoping the extent of documentation dataset creators are responsible for. We propose ways to address these challenges and develop an overall framework for evaluation that outlines how data curation concepts and methods can inform machine learning data practices.

2024-06-05

The 2024 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (publié)

Methods, Applications, and Directions of Learning-to-Rank in NLP Research

Justin Lee

Gabriel Bernier-Colborne

Sowmya Vajjala

Learning-to-rank (LTR) algorithms aim to order a set of items according to some criteria. They are at the core of applications such as web s… (voir plus)earch and social media recommendations, and are an area of rapidly increasing interest, with the rise of large language models (LLMs) and the widespread impact of these technologies on society. In this paper, we survey the diverse use cases of LTR methods in natural language processing (NLP) research, looking at previously under-studied aspects such as multilingualism in LTR applications and statistical significance testing for LTR problems. We also consider how large language models are changing the LTR landscape. This survey is aimed at NLP researchers and practitioners interested in understanding the formalisms and best practices regarding the application of LTR approaches in their research.

2024-06-01

Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: NAACL 2024 (publié)

Machine learning data practices through a data curation lens: An evaluation framework

Eshta Bhardwaj

Harshit Gujral

Siyi Wu

Ciara Zogheib

Christoph Becker

Studies of dataset development in machine learning call for greater attention to the data practices that make model development possible and… (voir plus) shape its outcomes. Many argue that the adoption of theory and practices from archives and data curation fields can support greater fairness, accountability, transparency, and more ethical machine learning. In response, this paper examines data practices in machine learning dataset development through the lens of data curation. We evaluate data practices in machine learning as data curation practices. To do so, we develop a framework for evaluating machine learning datasets using data curation concepts and principles through a rubric. Through a mixed-methods analysis of evaluation results for 25 ML datasets, we study the feasibility of data curation principles to be adopted for machine learning data work in practice and explore how data curation is currently performed. We find that researchers in machine learning, which often emphasizes model development, struggle to apply standard data curation principles. Our findings illustrate difficulties at the intersection of these fields, such as evaluating dimensions that have shared terms in both fields but non-shared meanings, a high degree of interpretative flexibility in adapting concepts without prescriptive restrictions, obstacles in limiting the depth of data curation expertise needed to apply the rubric, and challenges in scoping the extent of documentation dataset creators are responsible for. We propose ways to address these challenges and develop an overall framework for evaluation that outlines how data curation concepts and methods can inform machine learning data practices.

2024-05-04

ArXiv (prépublication)

Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models

Usman Anwar

Abulhair Saparov

Javier Rando

Daniel Paleka

Miles Turpin

Peter Hase

Ekdeep Singh Lubana

Erik Jenner

Stephen Casper

Oliver Sourbut

Benjamin L. Edelman

Zhaowei Zhang

Mario Günther

Anton Korinek

Jose Hernandez-Orallo

Lewis Hammond

Eric J Bigelow

Alexander Pan

Lauro Langosco

Tomasz Korbak … (voir 18 de plus)

Heidi Chenyu Zhang

Ruiqi Zhong

Sean O hEigeartaigh

Gabriel Recchia

Giulio Corsi

Alan Chan

Markus Anderljung

Lilian Edwards

Danqi Chen

Samuel Albanie

Jakob Nicolaus Foerster

Florian Tramèr

He He

Atoosa Kasirzadeh

Yejin Choi

This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are o… (voir plus)rganized into three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified challenges, we pose

2024-04-15

ArXiv (prépublication)

Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models

Usman Anwar

Abulhair Saparov

Javier Rando

Daniel Paleka

Miles Turpin

Peter Hase

Ekdeep Singh Lubana

Erik Jenner

Stephen Casper

Oliver Sourbut

Benjamin L. Edelman

Zhaowei Zhang

Mario Günther

Anton Korinek

Jose Hernandez-Orallo

Lewis Hammond

Eric J Bigelow

Alexander Pan

Lauro Langosco

Tomasz Korbak … (voir 18 de plus)

Heidi Chenyu Zhang

Ruiqi Zhong

Sean O hEigeartaigh

Gabriel Recchia

Giulio Corsi

Alan Chan

Markus Anderljung

Lilian Edwards

Danqi Chen

Samuel Albanie

Jakob Nicolaus Foerster

Florian Tramèr

He He

Atoosa Kasirzadeh

Yejin Choi

This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are o… (voir plus)rganized into three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified challenges, we pose

2024-04-15

ArXiv (prépublication)

Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models

Usman Anwar

Abulhair Saparov

Javier Rando

Daniel Paleka

Miles Turpin

Peter Hase

Ekdeep Singh Lubana

Erik Jenner

Stephen Casper

Oliver Sourbut

Benjamin L. Edelman

Zhaowei Zhang

Mario Günther

Anton Korinek

Jose Hernandez-Orallo

Lewis Hammond

Eric J Bigelow

Alexander Pan

Lauro Langosco

Tomasz Korbak … (voir 18 de plus)

Heidi Chenyu Zhang

Ruiqi Zhong

Sean O hEigeartaigh

Gabriel Recchia

Giulio Corsi

Alan Chan

Markus Anderljung

Lilian Edwards

Danqi Chen

Samuel Albanie

Jakob Nicolaus Foerster

Florian Tramèr

He He

Atoosa Kasirzadeh

Yejin Choi

This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are o… (voir plus)rganized into three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified challenges, we pose

2024-04-15

ArXiv (prépublication)

Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models

Usman Anwar

Abulhair Saparov

Javier Rando

Daniel Paleka

Miles Turpin

Peter Hase

Ekdeep Singh Lubana

Erik Jenner

Stephen Casper

Oliver Sourbut

Benjamin L. Edelman

Zhaowei Zhang

Mario Günther

Anton Korinek

Jose Hernandez-Orallo

Lewis Hammond

Eric J Bigelow

Alexander Pan

Lauro Langosco

Tomasz Korbak … (voir 18 de plus)

Heidi Zhang

Ruiqi Zhong

Sean 'o H'eigeartaigh

Gabriel Recchia

Giulio Corsi

Alan Chan

Markus Anderljung

Lilian Edwards

Danqi Chen

Samuel Albanie

Jakob Nicolaus Foerster

Florian Tramèr

He He

Atoosa Kasirzadeh

Yejin Choi

This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are o… (voir plus)rganized into three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified challenges, we pose

2024-04-15

ArXiv (prépublication)