Reward models (RMs) for LLM alignment often exhibit reward hacking, mistaking spurious correlates (e.g., length, format) for causal quality
… (see more)drivers (e.g., factuality, relevance), leading to brittle RMs. We introduce CROME (Causally Robust Reward Modeling), a causally-grounded framework using targeted augmentations to mitigate this. CROME employs: (1) Causal Augmentations, pairs isolating specific causal attribute changes, to enforce sensitivity, and (2) Neutral Augmentations, tie-labeled pairs varying spurious attributes while preserving causal content, to enforce invariance. Crucially, augmentations target LLM-identified causal rubrics, requiring no prior knowledge of spurious factors. CROME significantly outperforms baselines on RewardBench (Avg +5.4\%, Safety +13.2\%, Reasoning +7.2\%) and demonstrates enhanced robustness via improved Best-of-N performance across RewardBench, WildGuardTest, and GSM8k.